A used Subaru Forester is one of the best value purchases on the South Shore of Long Island. The Forester holds its value well, ages gracefully, and the Symmetrical AWD system that makes it great new is equally reliable with 50,000 or 80,000 miles on the clock. South Shore Subaru in Lindenhurst carries used and certified pre-owned Forester inventory for buyers in Babylon, Bay Shore, and across Suffolk County.
Bottom Line: A used Forester between $18,000 and $28,000 gives you the same AWD capability as a new one, often with EyeSight safety tech, at a fraction of the price.
- Certified pre-owned Foresters come with a 152-point inspection and extended warranty
- Foresters from 2019-2022 are the sweet spot for value vs. features
- EyeSight standard starting with 2019 models on most trims
What to Look for in a Used Forester
The current-generation Forester (2019 and newer) is the clear target for South Shore buyers. The 2019 redesign brought standard EyeSight pre-collision braking on most trims, a larger 8-inch touchscreen, and a more car-like ride. Foresters from 2019 through 2022 represent the sweet spot: enough miles to be priced attractively, but modern enough to have the tech and safety features that matter.
Key items to verify on any used Forester: check the CVT transmission fluid service history, inspect the timing chain cover gaskets for weeping (common on high-mileage older models), and verify EyeSight camera alignment. On well-maintained examples, these are rarely issues - but they’re worth checking.
Browse used Subaru Forester inventory at South Shore Subaru in Lindenhurst to see current pricing and mileage on available vehicles.
Certified Pre-Owned vs. Standard Used
Subaru’s Certified Pre-Owned program is one of the most comprehensive in the non-luxury segment. A CPO Forester must pass a 152-point inspection, be under 5 years old with fewer than 80,000 miles, and come with a powertrain warranty to 7 years or 100,000 miles from the original in-service date. Roadside assistance is included for 24 months.
Standard used Foresters are typically priced $1,000-$2,500 less than comparable CPO units. Whether that gap is worth it depends on how many miles remain in the original factory coverage, and how much peace of mind matters to you.
For buyers in Babylon and West Islip who plan to own the vehicle for 4-5 years and put significant miles on it, CPO certification is usually worth the modest premium. South Shore Subaru’s service team inspects every CPO vehicle before it goes on the lot. See our full guide to buying a certified pre-owned Subaru Forester on Long Island for a complete breakdown of what’s covered.
Ready to find your used Forester? South Shore Subaru has current specials on used and CPO inventory:
- View current new and used Subaru specials
- Schedule a test drive in Lindenhurst
- Browse all used inventory
Which Used Forester Trim Makes Sense?
The Forester Premium trim is the most common on the used market and hits the right balance of features and price. It adds heated front seats, a power moonroof, and blind-spot monitoring - the features most South Shore buyers actually want. Premium models from 2020-2021 typically land between $22,000 and $26,000 with 25,000-50,000 miles.
The base Forester is the value play at $18,000-$22,000 - but watch for missing EyeSight on pre-2019 base models. The Forester Sport adds 18-inch wheels and a sport-tuned suspension, which some Copiague and Bay Shore drivers prefer. The Limited and Touring trims approach new-car pricing in the used market and are better evaluated against current incentives on a new vehicle.
For a full breakdown of trim differences, see our Subaru Forester trim levels guide for Long Island buyers.
"A 2020 or 2021 Forester Premium with around 40,000 miles is one of the best used SUV values on the South Shore right now. You get EyeSight, heated seats, AWD, and typically 5-plus years of remaining reliability - all for well under $25,000. We put every used Forester through a thorough inspection before it goes out."
General Manager, South Shore Subaru
Buying a Used Forester Near Lindenhurst: The Process
South Shore Subaru’s used car process is straightforward. Browse available inventory online, contact the team to confirm the specific vehicle, schedule a test drive in Lindenhurst - which serves Babylon, Copiague, West Islip, Amityville, and Bay Shore - and get a transparent price before you sit down to finance.
There are no hidden reconditioning fees tacked on at the end of the deal at South Shore Subaru. The price you see on the vehicle listing is the price. Used Foresters sell quickly because they’re practical and in demand, so act on a specific vehicle when you find one that fits your needs.
Trade-ins are valued transparently during the process. If you have a vehicle to trade, get a trade-in estimate from South Shore Subaru’s team before visiting.
FAQ: Used Subaru Forester Near Lindenhurst
How many miles is too many on a used Forester? Subaru Foresters are known for longevity when properly maintained. A well-cared-for Forester with full service history at 80,000-90,000 miles is often a better buy than a neglected 40,000-mile example. Ask for the service records - that tells you more than the odometer reading.
Does South Shore Subaru buy used Foresters as trade-ins? Yes. South Shore Subaru values trade-ins as part of any used or new purchase. You don’t need to be buying a new vehicle to sell your current Subaru - they’ll evaluate and make an offer on your trade separately.
What’s the typical financing rate on a used Subaru at South Shore? Rates vary based on credit and loan term. Subaru Motors Finance offers used vehicle financing through the dealership. Contact South Shore Subaru’s finance team for current used vehicle financing options available in Suffolk County.
Do used Foresters come with any warranty at South Shore Subaru? CPO Foresters include a full powertrain warranty to 7 years/100,000 miles from original in-service date plus 24/7 roadside assistance. Non-CPO used vehicles include a limited dealer warranty per New York State used car buyer protections. Ask about any available extended coverage at time of purchase.
What is the closest South Shore Subaru location to Babylon? South Shore Subaru in Lindenhurst is the closest Subaru dealership to Babylon, NY - approximately 5 miles via Route 109 or Sunrise Highway. It also serves West Islip, Bay Shore, Amityville, and Copiague buyers.
South Shore Subaru in Lindenhurst is the go-to destination for used Subaru Forester shoppers across Suffolk County’s South Shore. Browse current used Forester inventory today and schedule a test drive when you find the right one.